Primary navigation
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/47e91/47e9192af77ec141f187e320a93a2e0083c81ab9" alt="Cover of Sight & Sound August 2000."
USA 2000
Reviewed by Tom Tunney
Our synopses give away the plot in full, including surprise twists.
1969. Frank Sullivan, a fireman and ham radio enthusiast, lives with his wife Julia and six-year-old son John in New York.
In the same house 30 years later the adult John, a policeman, sets up his late father's long neglected ham radio. Due to unusual climactic conditions, he is able to contact Frank, sitting in the same room with the same radio 30 years before. John tells his father that he will die the next day in a fire. Forewarned, Frank survives the blaze. But his survival has one unforeseen consequence: the unsolved 1969 case of a local serial murderer - which John is working on - now has 10 victims instead of three, one of whom is John's mother, Julia.
Briefed by John from the 1999 police files, Frank sets out to stop the mystery killer striking again. He saves one would-be victim by talking to her all night. The killer, Jack Shepard, a policeman, realises he is being followed when Frank zeroes in on his next victim. Shepard beats Frank up and steals his driving licence, which he leaves beside his victim's body. Frank becomes the police's prime suspect. John tells him to hide his wallet (which contains the killer's fingerprints) in the house. John retrieves it 30 years on and is able to identify Shepard as the killer.
Back in the 1969, Frank is arrested. After being threatened by Shepard in his cell, Frank escapes, pursued by the killer. Shepard appears to drown during a fight with Frank at the waterfront.
Later, John tells Frank that Julia is still due to be killed by Shepard. As they speak, Shepard appears: as a young man in 1969, he tries to kill Frank; and as an older man in 1999, he tries to kill John. In 1999, an older version of Frank turns up and shoots Shepard dead. Back in 1969, Shepard disintegrates.
In 1999 Frank, John and their family enjoy a game of baseball.
Frequency is the story of a father, a son and a holy ghost. The spiritual dimension of director Gregory Holbit's entertaining, if baffling film takes the form of sunspots in the night sky which allow detective John Sullivan to communicate with his father Frank 30 years ago. This intriguing idea - which sees information rather than people journey though time - sets Frequency apart from other time-travelling movies such as Time after Time (1979) to the Back to the Future series. But like these films, Frequency has its share of sly ironies which play on the audience's knowledge of the course of history: the adult John, for instance, gives his brother 30 years advance notice to invest in e-commerce; while back in 1969 Frank imagines mobile phones to look like "big field radios they have in the army".
But such references to contemporary reality are rare - perhaps an indication of the inherently preposterous nature of Toby Emmerich's screenplay. Despite a commendation from physics professor Brian Greene - who appears in the film, first as a young man in 1969, then 30 years later - it's difficult not to notice certain dramatic flaws in Frequency's speculative narrative logic. As the parallel realities pile up like successive drafts of a developing screenplay - John is able to tamper with the past by forewarning his father of key events - the tension drains from the film: if John is able to change the course of given events - you're left thinking - everything, including the danger posed by serial killer Shepard, is open for revision, for erasure (in his climatic fight with Frank in 1969, Shepard literally disintegrates). For the most part, Holbit distracts us from the manifest absurdities of his plot through taut and pacey direction. Having directed episodes of television's NYPD Blue, he's far better on the mechanics of police procedure than he is on the dizzying implications of his time-travelling scenario. There's also a impressive attention to detail - Frank's cigarette burn on the table, for instance, appears suddenly 30 years later - which suggests Frequency has at least superficially been well thought out.
Ultimately though, for all its multiplying versions of history and its chaos-theory approach to narrative causality, Frequency is more about preserving the past than changing it. Like Back to the Future and Peggy Sue Got Married, Frequency evokes the past as an innocent, more wholesome time. The scenes with Frank might be set in 1969 but there's little indication of the turbulent social change then taking place. First glimpsed in an all-night bar, Shepard, the serial killer with designs on John's mother, is the malevolent threat to the stability of the Shepard family unit. Having blotted Shepard from history, John recaptures the family values of his childhood in the film's final scene - an idyllic multi-generational game of baseball. This may smack of wish fulfilment, but then idea that the scene could be one of many alternative realities is never too far away to upset the tidy sense of closure.